Kundan Shah transformed Raj Kumar Santoshi’s concept, inspired by Bimal Roy’s classic ‘Sujata,’ into a charming romantic comedy, filled with delightful moments that celebrate laughter and tears in a perfectly enjoyable package. Preity Zinta plays Rekha’s ‘untouchable’ daughter, a role that mirrors Nutan’s in Roy’s original. Shah reinterprets untouchability with a modern, melodramatic twist. In this version, Shalu (Zinta) is the illegitimate daughter of her mother’s deceased husband. The first half of the film is filled with lighthearted pranks, primarily delivered by Zinta, who showcases a comedic talent reminiscent of Lucille Ball and Goldie Hawn. Arjun Rampal, playing her boss in disguise, attempts to keep up with his co-star’s energetic performance, but Zinta’s charisma shines through. Shah, returning to the romantic comedy style of his earlier work, like ‘Kabhi Haan Kabhi Na,’ expertly uses song sequences and playful courtship to showcase the chemistry between Zinta and Rampal. One song features the pair playfully interacting in a busy office. The first half establishes Zinta’s comedic timing. The second half introduces the sacrificial element, mirroring the narrative of ‘Sujata,’ where the adoptive daughter must sacrifice her love. Though familiar, the second half is handled with sensitivity. Zinta’s talent is more suited to the mischievous role. A pre-interval moment highlights her comedic timing with the synchronization of her laughter with a lamb’s mewing. The film then shifts, transitioning into a more serious tone. This marks the start of the romantic comedy’s shift towards melodrama, with Zinta’s character atoning for her perceived transgressions. The film also features villainous characters, portrayed in a way that feels like a nod to mainstream conventions rather than a necessity. The film belongs to Zinta from beginning to end. Rekha, as the mother, is somewhat sidelined, her presence limited, and her character displaying a shrewishness. Mahima Chowdhary, as Zinta’s stepsister, attempts to bring depth to her underwritten role. The film is gentle at its core, and the camera work along with the cast, makes ‘Dil Hai Tumhaara’ as enjoyable as a comforting treat on a summer afternoon.
